When it is needed
If there are justified doubts about conclusions on the cause of damage or extent of losses.
What we examine
- The entire report with appendices.
- Original documents, diagrams and test reports.
- Calculation tables and inspection materials.
Materials to prepare
- Complete report text and questions posed.
- Appendices, photographs and inspection records.
- Sampling records and laboratory test reports.
- Farm documents and specific comments on the conclusions.
Sample questions
- Do the objects and input data correspond to the questions posed?
- Are the inspection plan and sample representativeness justified?
- Have alternative damage causes been checked?
- Can the loss calculation be traced from input data to result?
- Which conclusions are supported by examinations, and which rely on unchecked assumptions?
How the work is carried out
- Check the examination contents and the materials' connection to the field or lot.
- Analyse methods, the causal model and calculation operations.
- Document comments, identifying their significance for particular conclusions.
Result
A review with verifiable comments and suggestions for clarifying questions or necessary further examinations.
What affects the conclusions
A review assesses the submitted examination. It does not replace a new field inspection or guarantee a particular dispute outcome.
Frequently asked questions
Can a pre-litigation examination be reviewed?
Yes. The entire document and appendices underlying its conclusions must be provided.
Will shortcomings be found in every report?
No. Analysis may show no significant comments or that they concern only some conclusions.